BeFree or Hiker Pro? How to choose a personal hiking water filter: a head-to-head comparison of weight, flow rate, and filter lifespan

Filling a KATADYN BeFree series water filter bottle at a stream
Filling the BeFree series directly from a stream

"Should I get the BeFree or the Hiker Pro for solo hiking?"

Both are made by KATADYN, both are rated for one person, and both are very lightweight, so many people are stuck between the two. The difference is actually quite clear: one is a soft water bag with a filter cartridge that you squeeze to drink; the other is a hand pump that pumps water into your water bag.

This article compares the manufacturer's specifications side by side and tells you which one to choose for different situations. First, one important thing they have in common: neither is designed to remove viruses.

The bottom line

  1. For the lightest, smallest option that lets you drink on the go: choose the BeFree 0.6L. It weighs about 59 g, the water bag is collapsible, and the maximum flow rate is 2 liters per minute.
  2. For slightly turbid water, to reduce off-flavors, or to pump water into your own water bag or bottle: choose the Hiker Pro. It weighs about 310 g, the filter cartridge contains activated carbon, and the manufacturer rates it for clear and occasionally turbid water.
  3. The filtration capacity is rated at the same level in the manufacturer's manuals: Both are rated to reduce 99.9999% of bacteria and 99.9% of protozoan cysts (Giardia and Cryptosporidium).
  4. Neither removes viruses, and neither can be used to desalinate seawater. If the water source is suspected of containing viruses or chemical contamination, it must be treated separately or you should find a different water source.

Side-by-side specifications

All figures in the table below come from the manufacturer's specifications and user manuals. For the BeFree, we are comparing the basic 0.6L model here. The filter cartridge specifications are the same for the 1.0L and other capacities; the difference lies in the capacity and water bag.

BeFree 0.6L and Hiker Pro specifications comparison (based on manufacturer's specifications and manuals)
Item BeFree 0.6L Hiker Pro
Weight About 59 g About 310 g
How to use Soft water bag with filter cartridge; drink directly from the mouthpiece after filling the bag with water Hand pump; use the intake hose to draw water and the outlet hose to pump water into a water bag or bottle
Flow rate Maximum 2 liters per minute About 1 liter per minute (about 48 pumps)
Filter media 0.1-micron hollow fiber membrane 0.2-micron fiberglass filter cartridge with activated carbon
Reduction rates in manufacturer's manuals Bacteria 99.9999%, protozoan cysts 99.9% Bacteria 99.9999%, protozoan cysts 99.9%
Filter cartridge lifespan About 1,000 liters (depending on the quality of the source water) About 1,150 liters (with the filter cartridge guard); the manual's tested value without the guard is 750 liters
Water source rated by the manufacturer Clear water Clear and occasionally turbid water
Cleaning method Shake or swirl after filling the water bag, or hold the filter cartridge and swirl it in water; do not squeeze the filter cartridge The outer layer of the filter cartridge can be cleaned; includes a cleaning sponge and silicone oil
Recommended number of users 1 person 1 person
KATADYN BeFree 0.6L Personal Water Filter
BeFree 0.6L: About 59 g, collapsible water bag
KATADYN Hiker Pro Hand Pump Water Filter
Hiker Pro: About 310 g, transparent body lets you see the water flow

Which one to choose for different situations?

When to choose the BeFree

  • For activities like trail running, cycling, fishing, and city travel where minimizing weight is a priority. The manufacturer says the folded water bag can fit into running shorts, cycling apparel, or a fishing vest.
  • When there is clear freshwater along the way and you want to fill the water bag whenever you can.
  • When you don't want to carry tools or backwash; if the flow rate slows down, you can clean it by shaking or swirling.

When to choose the Hiker Pro

  • When the water source is a lake or stream and is occasionally turbid. The intake has a 130-micron pre-filter screen that can extend the filter cartridge's lifespan.
  • When you want to pump water directly into your own water bag or bottle. The quick-release connector fits most outdoor water bags, and the EasyFill cap can attach to bottles of different sizes.
  • When you want to reduce off-flavors in the water. The filter cartridge contains activated carbon granules.
  • When you want to see the water flow and filtration process through the transparent body.

The weight difference is about 250 g, which is the most practical difference. However, both are rated for one person. For group use, you should look at gravity-fed or group-use models.

Common limitations of both

  • Neither removes viruses. The BeFree manufacturer's manual clearly states that it does not remove viruses, chemicals, radioactive substances, or particles smaller than 0.1 microns; the Hiker Pro's product description does not list viruses, so it should not be used for virus protection either. If the water source is suspected of containing viruses, it must be treated separately, for example, with purification tablets.
  • Neither can desalinate seawater. Neither model is rated to remove salt. For information on choosing a seawater desalinator, see how to choose a seawater desalinator.
  • The BeFree cannot be used when freezing. The manufacturer's manual warns against using it in freezing conditions, as a frozen filter membrane may allow microorganisms to bypass it.

How does maintenance differ?

The BeFree is cleaned by shaking or swirling, and all parts should be allowed to dry completely before storage; do not rinse it under running tap water. After using the Hiker Pro, continue pumping the handle to drain any remaining water from the body, and store the outlet hose and cap separately; remove the filter cartridge before long-term storage and let it dry. Detailed information on lifespan and storage can be found in How long do filter cartridges last? Water filter maintenance, storage, and purification tablet shelf life.

Frequently asked questions

Which is lighter, the BeFree or the Hiker Pro?

The BeFree 0.6L weighs about 59 g, while the Hiker Pro weighs about 310 g, making the BeFree much lighter.

Can either filter out viruses?

No. The BeFree manufacturer's manual clearly states that it does not remove viruses; the Hiker Pro is rated to remove bacteria, protozoa, cysts, algae, spores, and sediment, so it should not be used for virus protection.

How much difference is there in filter cartridge lifespan?

The BeFree lasts about 1,000 liters, while the Hiker Pro lasts about 1,150 liters (with the removable filter cartridge guard; the manual's tested value without the guard is 750 liters). Both vary depending on the quality of the source water; the dirtier the water, the faster the filter will wear out.

Are either suitable for group use?

The manufacturer rates both for one person. For group trips, look for models designed for groups, such as gravity-fed water filters like the Base Camp Pro.

No water filter is better than another; it just depends on which one is better suited for your backpack.


Sources

  • KATADYN manufacturer's specifications 8019946: BeFree 0.6L
  • KATADYN manufacturer's user manual: BeFree
  • KATADYN manufacturer's specifications 8019670: Hiker Pro Transparent
  • KATADYN manufacturer's user manual: Hiker Pro

Related products

Colors and availability are subject to the latest product page information.